Peer Review

The transcript discusses the contrasting reactions of historians and physicists to a book initially intended to blend history and science. The book, 'Worlds in Collision,' was transformed into a science book due to its reception. The transcript also explores the evolution of peer review, highlighting its role in publishing decisions and how it has shifted from advisory to gatekeeping. The discussion includes the historical context of peer review and its impact on the perception of scientific work.

Discuss the impact of the editor's decision on the publication of the book.

In what ways does the text suggest that the framing of a book can influence its reception?