Private Mediation Would Help in Hong Kong: McFadden

The transcript discusses the challenges of polarized negotiations, especially when conducted in front of live TV cameras. It highlights the mediator's perspective on starting negotiations from entrenched positions and the role of cameras in signaling transparency. The power dynamics, particularly the absence of the Communist Party of China, are analyzed, with an emphasis on communication lines to Beijing. The mediator's priorities include finding common ground and addressing face-saving needs for both sides. The discussion concludes with the importance of small steps and continuous dialogue to overcome deadlock.

What is a common starting point in most mediations?

• Immediate agreement

• A dramatic breakthrough

• Entrenched positions

• Public debates

How does the presence of cameras affect negotiations?

• It eliminates the need for mediators

• It can make discussions more performative

• It leads to more entrenched positions

• It ensures complete privacy

What is the role of the Communist Party of China in the discussed negotiations?

• They have given full authority to local representatives

• They have no influence over the negotiations

• They are directly involved at the table

• They are absent but likely have communication lines open

What is the first priority of a mediator in a conflict?

• To take sides with the stronger party

• To find common ground in private

• To avoid any form of communication

• To publicly announce the issues

What is a common expectation in any mediation situation?

• Deadlock at some point

• Complete agreement

• No need for further talks

• Immediate resolution

Why is face-saving important in negotiations?

• It ensures complete transparency

• It guarantees a quick resolution

• It allows parties to maintain dignity

• It eliminates the need for mediators

What is a key strategy to overcome deadlock in negotiations?

• Ignoring the other party's needs

• Continuing to talk and take small steps

• Ceasing all communication

• Taking large, dramatic steps