phil 110 final

hard determinism

• inconsistent tetrad

• incompatible with free will

• determinism is true

• compatible with free will

free will is...

• incompatible with the claim about God's existence

• the same as agency

• moral responsibility

• inconsistent tetrad

free will as an inconsistent tetrad

• determinism is false

• determinism is true

• our decisions and actions are events

• moral responsibility requires free will

if determinism is true then we have control over our actions and decisions

• true

• false

who was holbach

• determinist

• soft determinist

• hard determinist

• libertarian

what is the key challenge to hard determinism

• moral responsibility

• free will

• Holbac

• Chisolm

moral responsibility

• we have no agency

• our decisions and acitons are determined

• praise and punishment

• we can change our actions

Chisolm

• soft determinist

• libertarian

• hard determinist

• does not agree with hard determinism

libertarian

• agrees with hard determinsm but says we have free will

• agrees with hard determinism on everything

• does not agree with hard determinism at all

• does not agree with hard determinism except that we have no free will

agent causation

• some of our actions are free

• our actions are either determined or indetermined

• our actions are caused by us

• beings that do not have will can change determined events