Counterclaims

Parents should not be fined when their
children bully because it is difficult to
enforce. No matter how well a parent
communicates an anti-bullying
sentiment at home, they are not with
their children at school and can not
control their actions. People think the
fine will stop the thirteen million
bullying cases a year. However, a
majority of bullying never gets
reported so nothing would actually
happen to those children and their
parents.
Which sentence is the counterclaim?

• However, a
  majority of bullying never gets
  reported so nothing would actually
  happen to those children and their
  parents.
• Parents should not be fined when their
  children bully because it is difficult to
  enforce.
• No matter how well a parent
  communicates an anti-bullying
  sentiment at home, they are not with
  their children at school and can not
  control their actions.
• People think the
  fine will stop the thirteen million
  bullying cases a year.

Tags

CCSS.RI.8.8

CCSS.SL.8.3

CCSS.W.8.1A

CCSS.W.8.1C

Boys and girls should not be educated in
single-sex classrooms because it does not lead to a better education. Supporters of single-sex education believe that this will lead to fewer distractions in the classroom. Single-sex education reinforces stereotypes about boys and girls. Single sex female classes tend to be less hands-on, which is something that some girls need. Students will encounter both genders outside of the classroom so it is important they are exposed to this at an early age.
Which sentence is the counterclaim?

• Supporters of single-sex education believe that this will lead to fewer distractions in the classroom.
• Single-sex education reinforces stereotypes about boys and girls
• Single sex female classes tend to be less hands-on, which is something that some girls need.
• Students will encounter both genders outside of the classroom so it is important they are exposed to this at an early age.

Tags

CCSS.RI.8.6

CCSS.RI.8.8

CCSS.SL.8.3

CCSS.W.8.1A

Grocery stores should not ban disposable
plastic bags because they are not that
significant of a problem. Plastic bags
account for only a small percentage of
the waste in the world’s landfills. It is
true that although plastic bags are not
biodegradable, they are able to
be recycled. Most grocery stores have
stations where customers can recycle
their plastic bags.
Which sentence is the counterclaim?

• Plastic bags accounts for only a small percentage of the waste in the world's landfills.
• It is
  true that although plastic bags are not
  biodegradable, they are able to be recycled. 
• Most grocery stores have
  stations where customers can recycle
  their plastic bags.
• Grocery stores should not ban disposable
  plastic bags because they are not that
  significant of a problem.

Tags

CCSS.RI.8.6

CCSS.RI.8.8

CCSS.SL.8.3

CCSS.W.8.1A

Schools should not conduct random
drug tests because it doesn’t
significantly help children. Critics say
these random tests stop children from
using drugs in middle and high school.
Studies have shown, though, that some
children avoid sports so they aren’t
tested. If they aren’t involved in
extracurricular activities, they have
more time to experiment with drug
use.
Which sentence is the counterclaim?

• Studies have shown, though, that some
  children avoid sports so they aren’t
  tested.
• If they aren’t involved in
  extracurricular activities, they have
  more time to experiment with drug
  use.
• Schools should not conduct random
  drug tests because it doesn’t
  significantly help children.
• Critics say
  these random tests stop children from
  using drugs in middle and high school.

Tags

CCSS.RI.8.8

CCSS.SL.8.3

CCSS.W.8.1A

Schools should conduct random drug tests because it is beneficial to the health of children. Random drug tests stop many children from doing drugs in middle and high school. Many parents and adults feel that these drug tests are a violation of student privacy. Data shows that students who start using drugs in middle school are more likely to use them as adults. If they are detected in middle school, students.may be able to get help before it becomes a serious problem.
Which sentence is the counterclaim?

• Data shows that students who start using drugs in middle school are more likely to use them as adults.
• Many parents and adults feel that these drug tests are a violation of student privacy.
• Schools should conduct random drug tests because it is beneficial to the health of children.
• If they are detected in middle school, students.may be able to get help before it becomes a serious problem.

Tags

CCSS.RI.8.8

CCSS.W.8.1A

Parents should be fined when their
children bully because it will send a
message. Some say It is very difficult for
parents to manage their children
when they leave the house and go to
school. Despite this, thirteen million
kids are bullied each year and
something needs to be done. The fines
will encourage parents to focus on anti-bullying in the home.
Which sentence is the counterclaim?

• Despite this, thirteen million
  kids are bullied each year and
  something needs to be done.
• The fines
  will encourage parents to
  focus on anti-bullying in the home.
• Some say it is very difficult for
  parents to manage their children
  when they leave the house and go to
  school.
• Parents should be fined when their
  children bully because it will send a
  message.

Tags

CCSS.RI.8.6

CCSS.RI.8.8

CCSS.W.8.1A

Longer school days could harm a
community. Many school districts do
not have the money to pay teachers
to stay later. Also,students need
unstructured time for sports and
play. However, extended school days could prepare students for careers after
high school. 
Which sentence is the counterclaim?

• Longer school days could harm a
  community.
• Many school districts do
  not have the money to pay teachers
  to stay later.
• However, extended school days could prepare students for careers after
  high school.
• Also, students need unstructered time for sports and play. 

Tags

CCSS.W.8.1A

CCSS.W.8.1C

Cities and towns should not install video
cameras for surveillance because they do more harm than good. Video cameras are a violation of an American’s fourth
amendment rights which protects us
against “unreasonable search and
seizures”. When your image is captured and stored, it is done so without your permission. Major cities, though, have reduced their crime rate because of video surveillance. The money would be better spent hiring more police officers. This would make people feel safer.

• Major cities, though,  have reduced their crime rate because of video surveillance.
• When your image is captured and stored, it is done so without your permission.
• Video cameras are a violation of an American’s fourth
  amendment rights which protects us
  against “unreasonable search and
  seizures”.
• This would make people feel safer.

Tags

CCSS.RI.6.8

CCSS.RI.7.1

CCSS.RI.7.8

CCSS.RI.8.1

CCSS.RI.8.8

Voters should not be required to show a
picture identification at the polls because
it isn’t fair to millions of Americans.
Twenty million eligible
voters do not have a picture identification. For many, they can not afford it so this would mean that people of a lower socioeconomic status would be barred from voting. Requiring picture
identification, though,  would stop fraud at the
voting booths. 
Which sentence is the counterclaim?

• For many, they can not afford it so this would mean that people of a lower socioeconomic status would be barred from voting.
• Twenty million eligible
  voters do not have a picture identification.
• Requiring picture
  identification, though,  would stop fraud at the
  voting booths.
• Voters should not be required to show a
  picture identification at the polls because
  it isn’t fair to millions of Americans.

Towns should not ban the sale of disposable water bottles because it adds to a healthier lifestyle. According to the
International Bottled Water Association,
63% of people polled would choose a drink with sugar if bottled water wasn’t
available. Americans consume 1 billion
bottles of beverages a day; only a small
portion of those are bottled water.  Environmentalists, though, feel that the
almost 200 million disposable bottles
in landfills is a good reason to ban
them.
Which sentence is the counterclaim?

• Environmentalists, though, feel that the
  almost 200 million disposable bottles
  in landfills is a good reason to ban
  them.
  bottles of beverages a day;
• Towns should not ban the sale of disposable water bottles because it adds to a healthier lifestyle.
• Only a small
  portion of those are bottled water.
• According to the
  International Bottled Water Association,
  63% of people polled would choose a drink with sugar if bottled water wasn’t
  available.